Beyond Heritage Preservation


A re-examination of Queen Street Wes
A re-examination of Queen Street West

2022

Advisor: Nicolas Barrette

Collaborator: Michelle Li

Click [here] for the paper!


The Ontario Heritage Association wields considerable authority in shaping preservation guidelines citywide, with a focus on safeguarding historic structures based primarily on their visual appeal, including features like brick facades and architectural intricacies. This approach, while aiming to protect heritage, has led to a somewhat rigid preservation strategy that sometimes impedes urban development.

Consequently, conservation efforts often prioritize aesthetics over practicality, resulting in fully renovated interiors and the displacement of longstanding residents in favor of more affluent tenants. Amidst the interplay of private developers, municipal policymakers, and the imperative for economic growth, conservation policies have become subject to compromise, leading to a streetscape that is both layered with history and out of sync with contemporary needs. Within designated heritage districts like Queen Street West, this study underscores the cultural and architectural significance of specific buildings, proposing policy adjustments to allow for more flexible neighborhood revitalization.

In doing so, it prompts reflection on the democratic nature of adaptation and whether changes should align with or diverge from the original design. Ultimately, the historical value of a building is no longer solely determined by its intrinsic characteristics but is instead shaped by community dialogue and evolving societal values.
Queen Street Morpohology